This set includes five different shades of brown. The lightest color is called Blonde and is suggested for those with light to dark blonde hair. They have included an eyebrow pencil for the full spectrum of hair colors. From a marketing perspective, I found the packaging of the eye brown pencils to be odd because most people do not change their hair color from blonde to auburn to brown or black. I appreciate that they included so many eyebrow pencils in the same box.
I have dark brown hair and a melanated skin complexion. I chose the pencil intended for blondes, which was the lightest color, and it looked just fine on my eyebrows. I sampled the other colors in the box too. The other colors also looked fine on me. So, I would take their recommendations for matching hair color to pencil choice with a big grain of salt.
The pencil has a wide flared tip. I have only used an eye brown pencil with a sharp pointy tip. I could color in my eyebrow faster because the tip was wider than a pencil with a pointy tip. I used the pencil to fill in my eyebrows to make them look fuller. I was able to do that, and make my eyebrows look mostly natural. The tip was firm, which made it easier to create lines that were going in the same direction as my natural eyebrows. I prefer a hard pencil over a soft eyebrow pencil and eyebrow pomades because it is easier to control the pencil and to create a more natural looking eyebrow, which is always my goal.
I would not describe this as a professional eyebrow pencil. The quality is good, not great. The eyebrow pencil is waterproof. I was able to fill in my eyebrows and make them look fuller and natural. My eyebrows still looked like my eyebrows, which is what I wanted.
I also think it is interesting that these eyebrow pencils do not require a pencil sharpener. When you need more eyeliner, you unwrap the pencil from the top to expose more of the pencil. That is really convenient. Five eyebrow pencils for $15 is very economical. That is $3 per eyebrow pencil. This is a great buy at $3 per pencil.